Skip to content
Facts checked October 5, 2026 on official sourcesHow we score
On this page · 5 sections
  1. 01Quick verdict
  2. 02At a glance
  3. 03Scores by criterion
  4. 04Pros & cons
  5. 05Method & sources

At a glance

Our Stoney Acres and Successful Garden Designer compared on 8 decision criteria
CriterionOur Stoney Acres – Online Gardening School logoOur Stoney AcresSuccessful Garden Designer (Rachel Mathews) logoSuccessful Garden Designer
Editorial scoreWeighted average of our five criteria8.1/108.1/10
PriceAs published on the official siteThe Gardening Academy membership $25 a month or $250 a year; single courses from $29 (PVC Drip Irrigation) and $50 (Vegetable Gardening Basics) to $150 (Year Round Gardening, Seed Starting Simplified) (official course pages, October 30, 2026)Lower starting priceCharged in GBP with USD prices shown (October 30, 2026): Survey Formula, Food Garden Formula or 5 Minute Plant Expert £48-49 ($66); Plant Design Formula £198 ($264); Small Garden Formula £225 ($297), or £495 ($693) with feedback on 2 plans; Fast-Track £396 ($533); Great Garden Formula £997 ($1,299); Professional Diploma version £1,999 ($2,496)
Payment plansHow the cost can be spreadMembership billed monthly ($25) or yearly ($250), cancel anytime; installments offered at checkoutNot published
FormatHow you studySelf-pacedSelf-paced
DurationTime to finish or access periodSelf-paced video courses, from 90 minutes (PVC Drip Irrigation) to 5.5 hours (Year Round Gardening); membership with at least 4 live Q&A sessions a monthSelf-paced, start anytime, lifetime access; the Great Garden Formula has 95 lessons, 20 of them image galleries
CertificateWhat you receive at the endNot publishedSuccessful Garden Design diploma only with the Professional Diploma version, after Rachel reviews 5 coursework plans
Refund policyYour way out if it is not a fit30-day money-back guarantee on courses and on the membership, by email (official course pages, October 30, 2026).Not published
Best forWho it suitsbeginner and intermediate home vegetable gardeners in North America who want practical video courses and live Q&A with an experienced gardener.homeowners who want to design their own garden step by step before buying plants, and aspiring designers who want a practical method with optional feedback from a working designer.

“Not published” means the provider did not state it or we could not confirm it. Program data checked October 5, 2026.

Scores by criterion

Our Stoney AcresSuccessful Garden Designer
OverallTie
Our Stoney Acres8.1
Successful Garden Designer8.1
Curriculum 25% of scoreSuccessful Garden Designer +0.6
Our Stoney Acres7.8
Successful Garden Designer8.4

Our Stoney Acres: Practical vegetable gardening video course. · Successful Garden Designer: Design-principles courses from home to professional level.

Credibility 25% of scoreTie
Our Stoney Acres7.8
Successful Garden Designer7.8

Our Stoney Acres: Established gardening blog family. · Successful Garden Designer: Practitioner-led; no accreditation stated.

Value 20% of scoreOur Stoney Acres +1.1
Our Stoney Acres8.9
Successful Garden Designer7.8

Our Stoney Acres: $69 for about 5.5 hours of content. · Successful Garden Designer: Prices not visible.

Flexibility 15% of scoreTie
Our Stoney Acres9.5
Successful Garden Designer9.5

Our Stoney Acres: Self-paced on Teachable. · Successful Garden Designer: Self-paced online.

Support 15% of scoreSuccessful Garden Designer +0.6
Our Stoney Acres6.7
Successful Garden Designer7.3

Our Stoney Acres: No support described. · Successful Garden Designer: Support details not stated.

Scores out of 10 from our published method; the overall score is the weighted average.

Pros & cons side by side

Our Stoney Acres – Online Gardening School logoOur Stoney Acres
✓What we like
  • Live Zoom Q&A at least four times a month in the membership, with an instructor certified through Utah State University's Master Gardener program
  • Garden Pathway course: 5.5 hours in nine steps, from where to plant to soil and pest control
  • Single courses from $29 if you only need one skill
  • 30-day money-back guarantee on courses and the membership
  • Monthly planting guides by growing zone
!Watch out for
  • Year Round Gardening alone costs $150, against $250 a year for the whole membership
  • Access lasts 'as long as we continue to service the course', not guaranteed for life
  • Written for North American home growers; little for small-farm or commercial growers
  • No certificate or recognized credential
  • Older official pages still show outdated 2017 prices, which makes it easy to misjudge the cost
Successful Garden Designer (Rachel Mathews) logoSuccessful Garden Designer
✓What we like
  • Taught by Rachel Mathews, a garden designer with over 30 years of experience, teaching online since 2009
  • A clear ladder of courses, from a $66 survey course to a full professional course
  • Paid tiers include feedback from Rachel on your own plans (2 plans on the Small Garden tier, 5 on the diploma)
  • Lifetime access, start anytime, and you can ask Rachel questions in the members' area
  • A free base-plan surveying course comes with each design course
!Watch out for
  • Prices climb fast: $1,299 for the Great Garden Formula, $2,496 for the diploma version
  • UK designer and examples, so plant choices need adapting to US hardiness zones
  • The diploma is the school's own, not an accredited qualification
  • 'Going up soon' price notes with no date on some course pages
Career guideHow to become a master gardener: steps, costs and requirements

Method & sources

We score each program on curriculum, credibility, value, flexibility and support, using the provider’s official pages; see how we score. Prices and terms change: confirm them on the official site before you enroll. Compare more options in our gardening ranking.

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Our rankings are based on our editorial criteria; some partners may be featured more prominently. Read our affiliate disclosure.