Skip to content
3 min readFacts checked October 13, 2026 on official sourcesHow we score
On this page · 13 sections3 min read
  1. 01Quick verdict
  2. 02At a glance
  3. 03Scores by criterion
  4. 04What it costs you to sell
  5. 05Audience and reach
  6. 06Control and business tools
  7. 07The course experience for learners
  8. 08Support and refunds
  9. 09Pros & cons
  10. 10Who should choose which
  11. 11Alternatives
  12. 12FAQ
  13. 13Method & sources

At a glance

Thinkific and Udemy compared on 9 decision criteria
CriterionThinkific logoThinkificUdemy logoUdemy
Editorial scoreWeighted average of our five criteria8.5/10Higher score8.2/10
PriceAs published on the official siteBasic $40, Start $82, Grow $164 a month billed annually; $54, $109 or $219 billed monthly (as of October 13, 2026)For instructors: revenue share (37% of marketplace sales; 15% subscription pool from January 2026). For learners: Personal Plan from $13 a month; single courses advertised from $11.99 on October 13, 2026Lower starting price
Payment plansHow the cost can be spreadMonthly or annual billing (annual saves 25%); Thinkific Payments at 2.9%, extra gateway fee with third-party processorsLearners: Personal Plan billed monthly or annually, or pay once per course
FormatHow you studySubscriptionSelf-paced
DurationTime to finish or access periodMonthly or annual subscription.Self-paced; course length set by each instructor. Bought courses come with lifetime access to the content; Personal Plan access ends when you cancel
CertificateWhat you receive at the endCompletion certificates issued automatically to your learners.Certificate of completion (not an accredited credential).
Free trialWays to test before paying30-day free trial; no free planPersonal Plan may start with a free trial; its length is shown at sign-up and you're charged when it ends unless you cancel
Refund policyYour way out if it is not a fitUpgrade, downgrade or cancel anytime, including during the trial; no money-back guarantee stated on the pricing pageLearners: eligible single-course purchases refundable within 30 days (some only as Udemy credit); subscriptions not refundable unless required by law
Best forWho it suitscoaches, trainers and small businesses who already have an audience and want to sell courses, cohorts and memberships on their own branded site.Self-directed learners who know which certification exam they're sitting and want a low-cost video course or practice-test set from an instructor they've vetted.

“Not published” means the provider did not state it or we could not confirm it. Program data checked October 5, 2026. Comparison updated October 13, 2026.

Scores by criterion

ThinkificUdemy
OverallThinkific +0.3
Thinkific8.5
Udemy8.2
Curriculum 25% of scoreUdemy +0.5
Thinkific7.3
Udemy7.8

Thinkific: Creator platform, no learner curriculum. · Udemy: Varies by instructor; strong options exist for major exams.

Credibility 25% of scoreThinkific +1.1
Thinkific8.9
Udemy7.8

Thinkific: Major course-hosting platform. · Udemy: Marketplace model with uneven quality control.

Value 20% of scoreTie
Thinkific8.9
Udemy8.9

Thinkific: From $40/month billed annually. · Udemy: Single courses are usually inexpensive.

Flexibility 15% of scoreTie
Thinkific9.5
Udemy9.5

Thinkific: Monthly or annual billing. · Udemy: Self-paced with lifetime access.

Support 15% of scoreThinkific +1.1
Thinkific8.4
Udemy7.3

Thinkific: SLA on higher tiers. · Udemy: Instructor Q&A only.

Scores out of 10 from our published method; the overall score is the weighted average.

What it costs you to sell

The two charge creators in opposite ways: Thinkific charges a monthly fee, Udemy takes a share of each sale.

When we checked on October 13, 2026, Thinkific’s Basic, Start and Grow plans cost $40, $82 and $164 a month on annual billing, or $54, $109 and $219 month to month; annual billing saves 25%. Every plan includes unlimited courses. With Thinkific Payments, card processing costs 2.9%; using a third-party processor such as Stripe or PayPal adds a gateway fee that varies by plan. You set your own prices.

Udemy does not sell instructors a plan; it earns through its revenue share. In a November 2023 letter to instructors, Udemy said its marketplace revenue share of 37% was not changing, and that the instructor share of subscription revenue would drop in steps to 15% in January 2026. Udemy also runs frequent sitewide sales: on October 13, its banner advertised courses from $11.99.

A $49 course, 20 sales a year (our example) You receive
Thinkific Basic, annual plan $980 minus 2.9% processing and $480 of plan fees: about $472
Udemy marketplace at 37% About $363, less if a promotion discounts the course

The example uses our own price and volume, before taxes and other fees, and assumes you bring the Thinkific buyers yourself. On those numbers, the break-even is about 16 sales a year: below it, Udemy’s zero upfront cost wins; above it, each extra sale is worth about $47.58 on Thinkific against about $18.13 on Udemy.

WinnerTie. Both score 8.9/10 on value; the better deal depends on who brings the buyers.

Thinkific official site — program page
Thinkific: official program page · screenshot taken October 5, 2026 · source
Udemy official site — homepage
Udemy: official homepage · screenshot taken October 5, 2026 · source

Audience and reach

Udemy’s marketplace is its real advantage. Your course sits where learners already browse, in categories from development to music, inside a Personal Plan subscription that includes 28,000+ courses, and in plans sold to companies. In its 2023 letter, Udemy said it served more than 67 million learners, its own figure.

Thinkific brings no buyers. It gives you a website on your own domain, sales and student dashboards, and marketing tools, but you must bring traffic through email, social media, search, ads or partners.

WinnerUdemy.

Control and business tools

Thinkific is your own school. Basic includes unlimited courses, video lessons, quizzes and discussions, one community, up to 5 digital products, checkout with order bumps, gifting and coupons, abandoned-cart emails and a custom domain. Start adds live cohorts and coaching with unlimited Zoom sessions, completion certificates, assignments, bundles, upsells, payment plans and memberships. Grow removes Thinkific branding and adds B2B sales, invoicing, three communities and API access. Its AI tools include a course outline generator.

On Udemy, you work inside the marketplace’s rules: learners see your course next to competitors, sitewide promotions push prices down, and subscription earnings depend on minutes watched.

Our credibility scores reflect the platform model: 8.9/10 for Thinkific as a course-business tool, 7.8/10 for Udemy, where quality control across instructors is uneven.

WinnerThinkific.

The course experience for learners

From the student’s side, Udemy is the more complete product. Each course has instructor Q&A and a certificate of completion; the Personal Plan adds certification prep, practice tests and AI-powered coding exercises. Courses bought outright come with lifetime access, as long as the account is in good standing and Udemy keeps the license.

Thinkific gives you the tools to build that experience: quizzes, assignments, discussions, communities and completion certificates from Start. The result depends on your work, and as a platform it has no learner curriculum of its own, hence 7.3/10 against 7.8/10 for Udemy. Both score 9.5/10 on flexibility. Note that Thinkific’s Basic, Start and Grow plans list 10,000 current students.

WinnerUdemy, as a ready-made learning catalog.

Support and refunds

Thinkific starts every account with a 30-day free trial, which it says lets you test everything “before you pay a cent”, and lets you upgrade, downgrade or cancel at any time, including during the trial. Its pricing page does not state a money-back guarantee. Support is by email and chat on Basic and Start, and by phone and priority email on Grow. It scores 8.4/10.

Udemy’s refund rules are written for learners: eligible single-course purchases can be refunded within 30 days, sometimes as Udemy credit, and subscriptions bought on Udemy.com are not refundable unless the law requires it. As an instructor, your help comes from Udemy’s support center and instructor community. It scores 7.3/10.

WinnerThinkific.

Pros & cons side by side

Thinkific logoThinkific
✓What we like
  • Start plan covers the essentials: unlimited courses, live cohorts with Zoom, quizzes, graded assignments, certificates, payment plans, memberships and a custom domain
  • 30-day free trial on every account, so you can build your first course before paying
  • Built-in Thinkific Payments at 2.9%, with no extra gateway fee
  • Upgrade, downgrade or cancel at any time, including during the trial
!Watch out for
  • No longer a cheap start: the lowest plan was $82 a month billed annually ($109 monthly) on October 30, 2026
  • Thinkific branding stays on your site until the Grow plan at $164 a month (annual)
  • Using Stripe or PayPal instead of Thinkific Payments adds a gateway fee that varies by plan
  • A branded mobile app costs another $199 a month
Udemy logoUdemy
✓What we like
  • One course, one payment: $19.99 to $199.99, and the course content stays in your account
  • A very large cert prep shelf: Udemy counts more than 12,000 cert prep courses and practice tests in Personal Plan alone
  • Most purchases can be refunded within 30 days if the course isn't what you expected
  • Personal Plan, from $13 a month, lets you switch between instructors until one style clicks
!Watch out for
  • Subscriptions bought on Udemy.com are not refundable unless the law requires it
  • Quality varies by instructor; certificates are not accredited
  • Courses taken through a subscription are available only while it is active

Who should choose which

Expert with a newsletter or YouTube following
Thinkific logoPick Thinkific

On Thinkific you set your own price and pay a monthly plan plus card processing (2.9% with Thinkific Payments). Udemy's marketplace share for instructors is 37%.

First-time instructor with no audience
Udemy logoPick Udemy

Udemy lists your course in a marketplace learners already browse, with no plan to pay. You give up most of the revenue from those sales, but you can test demand at no upfront cost.

Educator running cohorts and a community
Thinkific logoPick Thinkific

Thinkific's Start plan includes live cohorts and coaching with unlimited Zoom sessions, completion certificates, assignments, memberships and payment plans for your students.

Alternatives to Thinkific and Udemy

Other online course platforms options we reviewed, ranked by editorial score.

Coursera logo
Coursera
9.2/10
From $59/mo

Career changers with a concrete plan of two or more Coursera certificates, such as a Google certificate followed by a specialization, who can study steadily for a year.

$299/yr

Working photographers, designers and video editors who want a big on-demand library plus live classes they can ask questions in.

edX logo
edX
8.7/10

Self-directed learners who want one specific course from a named university, and who want to try it free before paying for the certificate.

↪See all 15 online course platforms ranked

FAQ

Is Thinkific better than Udemy for instructors?

For building a business, yes. Thinkific scores 8.5/10 against 8.2/10 in our review, ahead on credibility and support and tied on value and flexibility. Udemy scores higher on curriculum as a learning catalog and is the easier start if you have no audience.

How much does Udemy take from instructors?

Udemy said in its November 2023 letter to instructors that its marketplace revenue share of 37% was not changing, and that the instructor share for subscriptions would fall to 15% in January 2026. Rates can differ for sales you drive yourself, so check Udemy's current revenue-share article.

How much does Thinkific cost?

On October 13, 2026: $40, $82 or $164 a month on annual billing (Basic, Start, Grow), or $54, $109 or $219 month to month. Thinkific Payments charges 2.9%; third-party processors add a gateway fee that varies by plan.

Does Thinkific have a free plan or trial?

No free plan, but every account starts with a 30-day free trial, and you can cancel anytime, including during the trial. Thinkific's pricing page did not state a money-back guarantee when we checked.

Which is better for learners, Thinkific or Udemy?

Thinkific is not a catalog; each school is run by its creator. Udemy is a learning marketplace with a Personal Plan from $13 a month, lifetime access to courses you buy, and 30-day refunds on eligible single courses.

Method & sources

We score each program on curriculum, credibility, value, flexibility and support, using the provider’s official pages; see how we score. The comparison above was written from these sources and re-checked against the official sites on October 13, 2026. Prices and terms change: confirm them on the official site before you enroll.

Also read for this comparison (October 13, 2026)

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Our rankings are based on our editorial criteria; some partners may be featured more prominently. Links marked as sponsored are affiliate links. Read our affiliate disclosure.